No Promises on Public Consultation

By Jane Cruickshank / October 13, 2026
the front of the library building - it's needing a lick of paint!

AFTER last week’s submission of a petition against proposals to move Stonehaven library to Viewmount, Aberdeenshire Council say they are considering their next steps – but offer no assurance of a full public consultation.

Last week, campaigners opposing the move lodged a 2,357-signature petition with the local authority. In an article in The Bellman, they also flagged their concerns regarding the lack of clarity surrounding the process, and the absence of any clear, formal process or statutory consultation.

Andy McArdle told The Bellman: “The Save Stonehaven Library Coalition is extremely concerned by the continuing lack of transparency around the library proposals. No business case has been published, no outcomes from the January engagement exercise have been shared, and there is still no confirmation of a proper public consultation.

”A recent Freedom of Information response confirms that the Council holds internal documents relating to both the January engagement exercise and the proposed relocation but has chosen not to release them. The Council has a statutory obligation to act transparently and involve communities meaningfully in decisions affecting local services. Residents simply do not know what is happening or why.”

Kirby Porter spent his career in library services. He said: ”I think the long delay is indicative of how officers, at the beginning of the process, misjudged not only how complex moving our library to Viewmount would be but also how strongly the community would be against it.

”Following the submission of our petition they know better now.”

Is the move now a runaway train?

Aberdeenshire Council are being tight-lipped about their intentions for the future of Stonehaven library – and specifically any plans for a public consultation.

An Aberdeenshire Council spokesperson said: ”Live Life Aberdeenshire encouraged community engagement from active library users in January, with more than 450 comments submitted and 245 people attending the sessions.

”Feedback from these initial sessions is currently under review and any petition will be considered in line with our petitions guidance. Ongoing discussions are taking place regarding next steps.”

It appears the next move may be a report to our Area Committee.

Cllr Sarah Dickinson told The Bellman the Kincardine and Mearns Area Committee will be consulted and asked for comment on any proposals relating to the Stonehaven Library before that report goes to Communities Committee for determination.

She said: ”I understand that the community is wary of what will happen given the strong feelings around this and frustrated by how long this is taking. 

”As officers have already said, a lot of detailed feedback was received through the engagement process that was held in January and subsequent emails to officers after that. Officers have also been gathering other information as they consider the options. The petition is further feedback and will go through due process.

”So, for me, this is not a runaway train. There is no report as yet. The work is ongoing.”

Campaigning to keep Stonehaven library in its current location – from left, Andy McArdle, Kirby Porter and Elizabeth Porter

Reprieve on Library Closures – TheBellman